Back to Product

Sitka Sandal Reviews

Brad G.

Jun 3, 2026

5/5

Best Flip Flops for fishing

These are the best flip flops I’ve owned. Very comfortable, non slip grip. Great for the boat and putting the boat on the trailer. Highly recommend, my wife steals them all the time.

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 131 lbs - 160lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Coyote · Size: 10

Michelle R.

Jun 2, 2026

5/5

very pleased with purchase

the sandals are true to size and very comfortable.

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Coyote · Size: 10

Beth U.

Jun 2, 2026

2/5

Too thin

My son tried two different sizes trying to like these, but ultimately felt they were not comfortable. He also thought they were too thin and flimsy. They are both being returned.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Coyote · Size: 12

Pam B.

Jun 2, 2026

5/5

Great Sandals

Great Sandals

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'3'' - 5'5'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Coyote · Size: 9

Talan F.

Jun 1, 2026

5/5

Sandal

awesome sandals, very comfortable!

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 131 lbs - 160lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Coyote · Size: 8

Shad S.

May 28, 2026

5/5

Awesome Sandal

Comfortable and look great. Liking them thus far.

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 9

Glen C.

May 25, 2026

5/5

Sitka sandal review

Super flip flops!

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Anthony R.

May 25, 2026

5/5

Comfortable

Very comfortable I wear a size 12 bought the 13 perfect fit.

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 13

Cameron

May 24, 2026

5/5

Best flip flops I’ve ever owned!

I do not typically leave reviews but here I am, coming back almost a year later to buy another pair and let you guys know that these are awesome! I have a wide foot (EE boot) and find that some flip flops are too tight on my feet but not these. These are some of the most comfortable flip flops I have put on and I also find they are much lighter than other flip flops I have purchased in the past from different brands. If the temperature is over 65 I have these bad boys on 90% of the time and would wear them year round if the weather would allow me to.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Brad C.

May 21, 2026

5/5

Next Level Comfort

Next Level Comfort

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Coyote · Size: 10

Ben J.

May 20, 2026

5/5

Sandals

Awesome, comfortable sandal. I would say it runs smaller than other sandals I’ve purchased.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6'3'' - 6'5'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Granite · Size: 12

Taylor P.

May 19, 2026

5/5

After break in, these will

After break in, these will be your favorite, most comfortable sandal!

Verified Buyer

Height: 6'3'' - 6'5'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Basic Black · Size: 13

David S.

May 19, 2026

5/5

Sandals

Very comfortable

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Aluminum · Size: 9

Kevin N.

May 18, 2026

4/5

Jury is still out

I just received these the other day, I have not worn them yet, only tried them on. I had to reorder a bigger size, they run small.

Verified Buyer

Military & Veterans

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Size: 9

Chad U.

May 18, 2026

3/5

Runs Small

I normally wear a size 9 1/2 in all shoes and ordered a size 10 and was too small for my feet. I gave them to my son who normally wears a 8 1/2 and they fit him good.

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 10

Bradley L.

May 14, 2026

5/5

Can stand in them all day!

I’m a fishing guide so I’m standing all day long. These are super comfortable. I gotta order a second pair to wear not on the boat so they stay clean! The best sandals I have had in a long time.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Granite · Size: 10

Rodney L.

May 14, 2026

4/5

Its a flip flop

seem comfortable

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Aquafade · Size: 12

Steven J.

May 14, 2026

5/5

Nice flip flops

Good fit True to size High quality

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Charles R.

May 14, 2026

5/5

Sandal

Made very well. Great color. True to size fit. Very lightweight and stylish. I would recommend this sandal.

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 9

Jaden M.

May 11, 2026

1/5

Made small

These shows are made small

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 10

Brian M.

May 9, 2026

5/5

Nice flip flops

Nice

Verified Buyer

Military & Veterans

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 11

Jay P.

May 8, 2026

5/5

This sandal is very comfy

This sandal is very comfy and stylish as well.

Verified Buyer

Pro

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Aquafade · Size: 11

NATHAN F.

May 6, 2026

5/5

Great sandal. For me it

Great sandal. For me it ran a bit small. I wear a 10. 5 consistently and I wish I would have ordered the 11.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Tim A.

May 5, 2026

5/5

Great fitting!

I love the way these fit and wear! I will be buying more!

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 13

Derrick H.

May 4, 2026

5/5

There great

They run a little small but there great.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 10

Freddie B.

May 2, 2026

2/5

Sandals

Sandals do no accommodate wide feet with little to no arch

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Coyote · Size: 12

michael r.

May 1, 2026

5/5

Comfortable

Comfortable sandles

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Size: 10

Josh L.

May 1, 2026

5/5

So far this sandal has

So far this sandal has held up very well

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 11

Ryan S.

May 1, 2026

5/5

Great flops

Bought them for a trip to Florida. Wore them the entire time. Very comfortable

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 10

Marc M.

May 1, 2026

5/5

Sitka Flip Flop

As usual, Sitka made it right. I have been a flip

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 8

Zachary M.

Apr 30, 2026

5/5

Sandal

Sandals are great! I have wide feet, so they are a little narrow but not too bad. Would be great to see a wide/extra wide size in the future.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 14

Grant C.

Apr 30, 2026

3/5

Decent sandals

I liked the sandals but they didn’t fit well on my feet. They seemed comfortable enough but don’t fit well on my feet.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Coyote · Size: 11

Keon L.

Apr 29, 2026

5/5

Great

Great product, soft and durable

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 311 lbs - 340lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Basic Black · Size: 12

Kali G.

Apr 29, 2026

5/5

great, comfy flip flop

great, comfy flip flop

Verified Buyer

Fit: True to size

Color: Coyote · Size: 13

Paul C.

Apr 29, 2026

5/5

Only have tried them on

Only have tried them on but they seem comfortable

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 9

Joseph H.

Apr 28, 2026

4/5

Sitka sandal

Good boating/fishing sandal

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11

John W.

Apr 28, 2026

5/5

Bought for my son. His

Bought for my son. His second pair. True to size. Good fit. Comfortable and he likes the look/design.

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 131 lbs - 160lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Aquafade · Size: 10

Aaron W.

Apr 27, 2026

5/5

Awesome sandals

Awesome sandals

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 251 lbs - 280lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 13

Giancarlo J.

Apr 27, 2026

5/5

Great buy for the summer

They are so comfortable I wear em to church! Also I’m an 11 and had to get a 13 I also have a wide and tall foot so do as you please with that information

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 281 lbs - 310lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 13

Todd T.

Apr 27, 2026

4/5

Comfortable

Very confortable sandals. The rubber soles squeak a bit when walking with sweaty feet. But I'm hoping once broken in a bit more, this will stop.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 13

Claude G.

Apr 26, 2026

5/5

Best flip flops I’ve ever

Best flip flops I’ve ever had !

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Coyote · Size: 13

Charles V.

Apr 26, 2026

5/5

Excellent quality

Comfortable and stable

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 10

Patrick T.

Apr 24, 2026

5/5

Love them, extremely comfortable and

Love them, extremely comfortable and great quality

Verified Buyer

Military & Veterans

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 251 lbs - 280lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 11

Brian K.

Apr 23, 2026

5/5

Nice

Nice Sandles that fit true to size

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 10

Calvin E.

Apr 21, 2026

5/5

New Beach Favorite

The new Sitka Flip Flops are my Favorite at PCB. This is my second trip this year and they work perfect!

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 11

Casey G.

Apr 21, 2026

5/5

Nice sandal

Nice sandal runs about . 5 size too small

Verified Buyer

Military & Veterans

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 281 lbs - 310lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Aquafade · Size: 13

Paula L.

Apr 21, 2026

5/5

Great sandals

Comfort and quality

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 10

Trey V.

Apr 21, 2026

5/5

The best

Greg product

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Coyote · Size: 12

Nathan D.

Apr 21, 2026

1/5

Poor fit and color

I ordered Optifade elevated and the color looks more like Optifade cover…poor fit. I wear a size 10 in everything Sitka footwear but had to return for an 11 and they still run small and the fabric inbetween my toes is ungodly uncomfortable. I wouldn’t recommend these.

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11

Jonas C.

Apr 20, 2026

5/5

Bought for wife

Bought smallest size for wife and she loved them.

Verified Buyer

Height: 5' - 5'2'' · Weight: below 100lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11