Back to Product

Sitka Sandal Reviews

Wyatt C.

Mar 30, 2026

4/5

Runs Small

Just a tad Small I'm a 12 in most other brands and that leaves me a little room for error with the heel. But these are cutting it close I would size up.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 251 lbs - 280lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 12

BREE S.

Mar 30, 2026

5/5

Best sandals ever

Love these! Best ones I have ever had Super comfortable

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11

Noah R.

Mar 30, 2026

5/5

5 star

I wear a size 9 but a 10 in these

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 131 lbs - 160lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 10

George F.

Mar 30, 2026

3/5

Not comfortable

Not very comfortable I can feel the "ridges" in the soles.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11

Christopher J.

Mar 29, 2026

5/5

Fit perfect - true to

Fit perfect - true to size.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 11

Hunter O.

Mar 29, 2026

5/5

I wear size 11 1/2

I wear size 11 1/2 shoes and size 12 works perfect

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 12

Gary C.

Mar 28, 2026

5/5

Comfortable and great looking.

Comfortable and great looking.

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 10

David S.

Mar 28, 2026

5/5

They are very comfortable I

They are very comfortable I love wearing them. I normally wear a 10-10. 5 and I had to send my first set back and the 11's fit amazing.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 10

Edwin D.

Mar 27, 2026

5/5

My foot is a normal

My foot is a normal 10. 5 size. These fit me true to size, and I find them comfortable to wear

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11

peter e.

Mar 25, 2026

2/5

Odd fit

I wear a 9 in just about every shoe/boot/sandals I own, these while are slightly to narrow for me they will stretch ( I have wide feet) the edge of my heel hangs off a bit and my toes dont seem to reach far enough forward. These just seem slightly smaller than ever other size 9 shoe,boot, sandal I have ever worn.

Verified Buyer

Pro

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Gabriel V.

Mar 25, 2026

5/5

Ordered a 12 originally, unfortunately

Ordered a 12 originally, unfortunately they were small. Requested exchange for 13s and they feel and fit great.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Size: 13

Brock G.

Mar 25, 2026

5/5

Love these sandals! They fit

Love these sandals! They fit great. I would definitely say true to size. So get up a size if you want a good fit.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 12

Mark M.

Mar 24, 2026

5/5

Sitka sandals

Good fit, form, and function. Should do the trick.

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11

Josh F.

Mar 24, 2026

5/5

Good sandal

I bought a pair, liked them a lot and bought a second pair in a different color. They are really comfortable. More comfortable than most sandals. Good footbed for great support and that is why I purchased a second pair.

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 131 lbs - 160lbs

Fit: True to size

Ethan W.

Mar 24, 2026

5/5

Very Comfortable & Versatile

I recently purchased two pairs. One for land and one for the water. Being a saltwater guide, I am constantly on the look for footwear that accommodates my needs. These sandals have checked all the boxes. Very comfortable, even when wet, fast drying, no annoying dye stains on your feet after being wet, and most importantly the cushioning acts as a great shock absorber which leads to a lower amount of back and knee pain when being out all day. I would highly suggest these to anyone who spends long days in sandals. Fantastic product

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Size: 12

Noah C.

Mar 23, 2026

5/5

Great fit and super comfortable

Haven’t worn flip flops in a couple years but man are these nice. Out of the box they fit perfect and are easily one of my most comfortable shoes to wear every day. I would recommend to anyone that needs a shoe they can walk around in all day and still take to the beach/lake.

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 131 lbs - 160lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Coyote · Size: 9

Eli K.

Mar 23, 2026

5/5

Good

Fit perfectly and look amazing

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 131 lbs - 160lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11

Josh T.

Mar 23, 2026

3/5

Well made but uncomfortable

Seem to be well made. Straps are comfortable but the something is off with the shape of the insole. Start hurting the arches of my feet after wearing for awhile. They run a little small also.

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 10

Ryan H.

Mar 23, 2026

5/5

Comfortable

Very comfortable for a flip flop.

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 10

Mark H.

Mar 23, 2026

5/5

My favorite flip flops

Love the feel of these flip flop on my feet. Very soft on my feet at the same time the soles on them provide good stability. Love the color.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 11

Corey M.

Mar 23, 2026

5/5

Comfortable sandals

Can walk all day in these sandals.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 251 lbs - 280lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 13

Michael W.

Mar 23, 2026

5/5

flipflop

feel great . . . .

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 9

Bailey M.

Mar 23, 2026

5/5

Sandles

These flip flops are great on the boat and just in all a great wearing shoe

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 131 lbs - 160lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11

Rick D.

Mar 22, 2026

4/5

Size

Definitely order a bigger size other then that I love sitka products

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Size: 10

Jack O.

Mar 22, 2026

5/5

Deck sandles

Fantastic, no slip Perfect!!!

Verified Buyer

Pro

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Coyote · Size: 9

EDWARD M.

Mar 22, 2026

3/5

Hard to brake in

Hard to brake in

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 13

Brian D.

Mar 22, 2026

5/5

Nice

A great pair of flip flops

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 10

Sammy J.

Mar 22, 2026

5/5

Worth the price.

Amazingly thick flip flops. They do run small so order a size up.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 14

Stuart S.

Mar 21, 2026

5/5

Awesome sandals

Super comfortable

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 131 lbs - 160lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Coyote · Size: 9

Damien W.

Mar 21, 2026

5/5

No more reefs

Best sandal on market

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 12

Fred O.

Mar 19, 2026

1/5

Sandal Review

Nicely constructed, hugely undersized. Had to go up two sizes over my normal size. Would have given them a “5” Star rating if the sizing wasn’t so far off.

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 10

Walter C.

Mar 19, 2026

5/5

South Florida Upland hunting club

Amazing sandells used all the time super comfortable. I used before and after every hunt

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 11

Brantley D.

Mar 18, 2026

5/5

Awsome comfortable

Awsome comfortable

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 131 lbs - 160lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 12

Rell S.

Mar 18, 2026

5/5

Sandals

Good fit and Quality

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 10

Austin A.

Mar 18, 2026

5/5

Flip flops

Absolutely love them!

Verified Buyer

Pro

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11

Jonathan B.

Mar 18, 2026

5/5

Sandals

Love them I got two pairs! Very comfortable and look awesome

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Size: 9

Mike S.

Mar 18, 2026

5/5

Sandals

Love the new flip flops. Got two pairs

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 12

Tye K.

Mar 18, 2026

5/5

Quality

Good and comfortable. . feels like they will last

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11

Roger B.

Mar 18, 2026

5/5

Sitka sandals

Very comfortable looking forward to wearing them this summer

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 12

Brad H.

Mar 18, 2026

5/5

Outstanding flip flops

The best I have ever worn!

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11

Costa G.

Mar 18, 2026

5/5

Sandals

Thought I would try these and just like all Sitka gear awesome flip flops

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 10

Richard j.

Mar 18, 2026

4/5

Good sandals

Very comfortable sandals fit well.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 281 lbs - 310lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 13

Kerry G.

Mar 18, 2026

5/5

Perfect fit

Comfortable and fit perfect. Just need some warm weather to see how they hold up.

Verified Buyer

Military & Veterans

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover

Demetri S.

Mar 18, 2026

5/5

Sitka Sandals

Amazing sandals. Will buy another pair soon.

Verified Buyer

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 9

James H.

Mar 18, 2026

5/5

Happy with purchase

Very comfy. Great sandal

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Coyote · Size: 10

David A.

Mar 17, 2026

5/5

These sandals are great

These sandals are the perfect fit. Comfortable and easy to wear

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 13

Barry B.

Mar 17, 2026

4/5

Good product

Very nice flop comfortable

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Coyote · Size: 11

Scott L.

Mar 17, 2026

3/5

Look great. Not enough heal

I really wanted to love these. They seem like they’re made very well, they look great and they’re quite comfy until they’re not. They have big arch supports, but not enough support in the heal area so they feel like they set your heels down and your toes in the air. It’s almost like they hyperextended your leg and they hurt my knees. I wore them for a couple of days thinking they would break in and get better. The arch support seemed to level out and not be quiet as extreme, but still felt like you had to stand on your tippy toes to stand right. I gave them to my 18-year-old son and he seems to really like them.

Verified Buyer

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 12

Jonathan E.

Mar 17, 2026

5/5

The only sandals I’ve ever liked

These are the only sandals that I have ever been able to wear for an extended period of time. They were perfect on our cruise.

Verified Buyer

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 10

Jeremy C.

Mar 17, 2026

5/5

Nice!

Great sandal, very comfortable

Verified Buyer

Pro

Height: 6'3'' - 6'5'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Sitka Black · Size: 6